Welcome to 3-2-1 Tuesdays with Better Wellness Naturally- The Fear of Being Seen: Why Authenticity Sparks Anxiety
- Admin
- 13 hours ago
- 4 min read
Thank you for joining us for 3-2-1 Tuesdays!
Quick bits of therapeutic info and learning, ideas, concepts, and quotes.
Brought to you by Better Wellness Naturally
3: Keys
2: Concepts
1: Quick Article
"Vulnerability is not winning or losing; it’s having the courage to show up and be seen when we have no control over the outcome." —Brené Brown
3 Keys
You Being You: What are you really afraid of?
Showing our authentic self can feel risky, and even showing the least bit of vulnerability is terrifying for most of us. While we may long be truly seen, we end up hiding parts of ourselves because we’re afraid of being judged.
Are you creatively defensive?
We all find ways to protect ourselves in various situations: through jokes, stories, or through avoidance of people, places, or new experiences. These defensive habits may have once felt necessary and may have even kept us safe at some time in our life. What about the opportunity cost now? And does this lead to resentment for many of us? Yes.
Small steps of visibility matter.
Being seen doesn’t mean revealing everything all at once. It can start with tiny gestures: sharing a thought, expressing an opinion, taking the lead, showing up, or doing something new. Each small step strengthens self-trust, which, in turn, creates pathways to new connections.
A Couple of Concepts
Social Risk
Plenty of people feel uneasy in new social settings, and opening up can trigger a quick jolt of regret or self-doubt. Pop-psych calls it a “vulnerability hangover,” though it’s simply the brain reacting to what it reads as social risk. Calling it out for what it is takes the edge off and keeps the moment from spiraling.
Shame Shields
A shame shield is a protective behavior we use to manage the discomfort of feeling exposed, judged, or inadequate. It’s not a formal diagnostic term — it’s a shorthand for the strategies people use to keep shame at bay.. It isn’t dramatic; it’s subtle and includes behaviors such as changing the subject, smoothing things over, cracking a quick joke, or aiming for flawless so there’s nothing to for someone else to criticize. These moves create space where closeness should be. Awareness cuts through the autopilot and brings the conversation back into real time.
A Quick Overview:
Are You Brave Enough to be Seen?
Humans are wired for connection. We’re an interdependent species and yes, we do require human connections for survival. Our nervous systems calibrate through co-regulation, and the brain’s social circuitry—especially the networks tied to safety, bonding, and emotional stability—develops through consistent interpersonal contact. Those relational exchanges influence everything from stress hormones to immune function, which is why meaningful connections aren’t optional; they actually shape how we thrive.
Being seen and understood activates our brain’s reward centers, releasing oxytocin and creating warmth, trust, and safety. Yet, the fear of judgment can trigger the amygdala—the brain’s alarm system.
Research shows that small acts of authenticity actually increase likability. People perceive those who show vulnerability as more relatable, trustworthy, and genuine.
And still, how often do our own minds often trick us into thinking hiding is safer?
The tension is built into our biology. We’re driven to bond, yet our threat circuitry is quicker than our social circuitry. The amygdala fires in milliseconds; the prefrontal regions involved in perspective-taking and relational assessment take longer to come online. So, the first wave is often a jolt of “pull back,” even when nothing is actually wrong.
What feels like shrinking is usually the nervous system defaulting to protection. Micro-freeze responses—tightening the breath, scanning for disapproval, mentally rewinding what we said—are early signs of this. They’re small, but they set the trajectory of the interaction. If we don’t notice them, the body runs the exchange for us.
Awareness works because it interrupts that automatic loop. When we recognize the physical cues of withdrawal, we shift activity toward regions of the brain that regulate social engagement: the medial prefrontal cortex, the anterior cingulate, and the vagal pathways tied to communication and prosody (how the voice conveys safety or tension). That shift doesn’t force openness; it simply gives us access to it.
With repetition, the system updates. The brain begins to associate relational exposure with accurate feedback rather than imagined threat. That’s how tolerance for being seen grows: not through grand leaps, but through brief moments where protection eases and connection is allowed to land.
References:
Brown, B. (2012). Daring Greatly: How the Courage to Be Vulnerable Transforms the Way We Live, Love, Parent, and Lead. Gotham Books.
Gilbert, P. (2010). The Compassionate Mind: A New Approach to Life’s Challenges. New Harbinger Publications.
Goleman, D. (2006). Social Intelligence: The New Science of Human Relationships. Bantam.
Kross, E., & Ayduk, O. (2017). Self-Distancing: Theory, Research, and Current Directions. Advances in Experimental Social Psychology, 56, 81–136.
We’d love to have you join us on retreat!
For more info and to Retreat with us: www.BetterWellnessRetreats.com
by Laura Weber Garrison, PhD
New Review:
“Reading Damaged Rudders feels like sitting with someone who really cares and really gets it. Dr. Garrison doesn’t sugarcoat, yet she writes in a way that makes the hard truths land with compassion. The mix of research and real-life understanding made me stop, reflect, and actually apply what I was reading. It’s not just another self-help book—it’s a companion for the work of healing.”
Better Wellness Naturally is now on Substack!
We’re creating a dedicated space for deeper reflections, healing insights, and meaningful conversations. That means more resources, inspiration, and guidance—delivered straight to your inbox!
If you already enjoy 3-2-1 Tuesdays, you’ll love what’s coming.
Comments